Our Valentine's Day survey attracted more respondents than any since
we started doing them, despite a server glitch that prevented people from
voting most of one night. We were reminded by several SNET Internet
subscribers that we perhaps should have included an answer that was tailored
to reflect disenchantment with the commercialism of Valentine's Day, but
we felt that giving the opportunity to brand the so-called holiday a "trivial
nuisance" covered the negative side adequately. Roughly a quarter
of all respondents chose that answer.
A couple of writers suggested the results would have been more interesting
if we asked for more information from respodents, so that we could break
out the answers by sex, marital status and age. Maybe someday we'll add
such minor sophistication, but for now we're content to keep this as simple
as possible.
We were intrigued that the answer that Valentine's Day is "a good
excuse for romance" was the least popular response, with about 18
percent. Combine that with the 33 percent who chose "a good day for
surprises" and we had just over half, a bare majority, who seem favorably
inclined towards the day. About 23 percent indicated that Valentine's
Day is something of a letdown, and THAT group was well-represented among
those who sent us email on this survey.
The final results were:
Q: I think Valentine's Day is:
- A trivial nuisance - 3,371 (24.9%)
- An excuse for romance - 2,465 (18.2%)
- Usually a letdown - 3,141 (23.2%)
- A day for surprises - 4,520 (33.4%)
Here are your comments:
"I believe in the
fairy tales, love the thought of the Easter Bunny, and definitely believe
in Valentine's Day being for surprises. This is the magic of life!"
J.D.
"I vote usually a
letdown because ... (and I quote) ... 'I was going to get you a card,
but the store was crowded, I didn't get a chance, no parking to get in
the store, but pick something out and I'll pay for it.' ... If I
needed something, I would buy it. It would be better if the individual
came up with a surprise for a special occasion, not excuses!" P.R.
"I like to think of
it as an excuse for romance ... goodness knows we need as many excuses
as we can get!" N.W.
"Valentine's Day is
just another day of the year. It is an excuse for men to indulge their
women in chocolate and then turn around to tell them that if they eat
the whole box they will get fat. Men send roses which in turn die a few
days later. So what's the point. There is none. It should be called Sex
Day. The whole scenario almost always leads to the bedroom. Some skimpy
lingerie and body oils are often used. Why must couples wait until Valentines
to engage in the best sex of their lives?" T.R.
"I think women, instead
of getting flowers, candy, nights out, etc., should get up off of their
tushes, and do something for the men (on Valentine's Day.) The women always
bemoan that it's a man's world (because we made it so), so ... get up
show some spunk, be proactive. Besides, it's only one day of the year.
Gals, you are women (listen to your own rhetoric, i.e. any woman is worth
ten men, etc.) Do something original.--show the family neanderthal that
active romance gives as well as it gets." B.S. Editor's
note: Yes, those are his real initials.
"I think Hallmark
has made way too much out of the holiday. My daughter's preschool class
made mailboxes and will have a party the friday before Valentine's Day.
I think that is a little off track. I think someone should take the time
and find out just who St. Valentine was and what his connection to lovers
is. Now that would be interesting." M.C. Editor's note:
There are a number of hypotheses on what got Valentine's Day started.
Click here
for a page with a couple of them.
"I think it's a day
created by cardmakers to make money." M.M.
"Valentine's Day,
like most American holidays, has been violated by the grab for the mighty
dollar. Big business has done more for destroying the working class' confidence
in it than foreign markets, trade deficits, third world competition, etc.
The romantic compulsions of remembering loved ones (parents, friends,
children, etc.) has been replaced by feelings of guilt if one does not
express emotional feelings with a Hallmark card, "Say It With Flowers,"
a sampler box of candy, mink coat, southern cruise, 18 holes at the local
golf course, etc. How about a simple telephone call: "Hi Mom, I know I
talked with you yesterday, but I'm calling you today, mom, best friend,
just to thank you for being there for me all these year, etc." Do you
agree that's got to be worth more to her than the chocolates that she
shouldn't eat, the flowers which will wilt in days, the card with someone
else's sentiments stamped on it? Surely, these things may be consumed
or saved because they are material. But that telephone call will live
in her memory for the remainder of her days. She will shed a tear of happiness
and tell you how much she loves you. So, to big business on Valentine's
day I say, pray to St. Valentine for foregiveness." P.M.
"How can anyone say
anything bad about Valentines Day? i think it is a time of year when you
can express your love for others easily. You have an excuse to tell them."
J.W.
"I think everyone
who thinks Valentine's Day is 'a trivial nuisance' needs to be hit with
one of Cupid's arrows." J.J.M.
"I just want to say
that Valentine's Day is an excuse for romance. I do not believe in it
because it means "to realize how much you love someone and get them a
gift" or something like that. Anyway, romance doen't even happen in my
household. We both go to work, don't expect anything except a "Happy Valentine's
Day' welcome, and then go to bed." M.O.
"I think it is usually
a letdown! Most men only do something on that day for a woman to win them.
After five years with the same man, I bought him a red rose for Valentine's
Day. I had it on the table with a card for him when he got home from work.
The first thing he said when he walked in the door was 'Who the heck bought
you that?' That's real romance and a wasted rose!" L.K.
"How many people are
actually able to celebrate Valentine's Day with someone who is 'special'
to them ???? 1) LESS THAN 1/3; 2) ABOUT HALF; 3) MORE THAN HALF 4) EVERYONE."
B.T. Editor's note: We guessed about half ...
"I think everyone
likes Valentine's Day - as long as they have a Valentine to share it with!"
M. and N.'s Mom
"What do you do without
a date on Valentine's Day? a) Pig out (no one wants to date you anyhow)
b) Find a date now c) Watch 'toons d) Sports time." C.S.
Editor's note: *Everybody* wants to be a survey designer ...
"I think Valentine's
Day is a day full of suprises, you never know what youll receive."
F.R.
"It is a day to show
the person you love more than life itself, how much they mean to you.
It is also a day like any other day when you are that much in love."
B.A.C.
"It might have been
better to break it down to a 'good' excuse for romance and a 'bad' excuse
for romance." J.B.
"In my house it isn't
Valentine's Day---It is the Daytona 500!" G.S.
"(Valentine's Day)
is my favorite holiday because there's little or no holiday pressure to
go out and buy buy buy. The surprises can be sweet. If I choose, I can
make a big deal out of the day, or just let it happen. I wish Christmas
was more like Valentine's Day." G.G.
Previous survey results are available.